American Shorthair kittens & cats in Salida, Colorado

Petunia is a very sweet, lovey girl. We took her in from a friend in the beginning of the summer (2024). We have a male cat who doesn't want anything to do with her but she is very intimidated by him. Petunia is too nervous to eat when anyone is around and despite getting three litter boxes to give her plenty of choices, she never seems to finish her business in them. I believe she's too scared of our male cat. When it is just her and people/the dog, she does fine, even plays. Over all, her quality of life just doesn't seem to be happy because of our other cat. We've tried to make changes to help her adapt and be a happier kitty but it's come to a point where my husband wants her gone do to the messes she's been leaving and us being unable to find a better situation for her. Petunia loves to play, snuggle, and she loves treats! She is very vocal and loves to give forehead kisses. It hurts my heart to have to let her go, but I want her to find a better family who can meet her needs.